My first “bucket list” trip was to Pebble Beach Resort in 2021. This year’s bucket list is Pinehurst Resort in North Carolina to play Pinehurst #2, Pinehurst #4, Pinehurst #8 and Tobacco Road. You must stay at the Pinehurst Resort to play the “bucket list” courses #2 and #4. We stayed in the Golf Terrace 208 Condo on Pinehurst #5 – in the distance, we could see the main Pinehurst Clubhouse from the balcony; as well as watch golfers playing the 18th hole in front of the condo. It was a great vibe staying in the condos. I wrote a blog with “non-golf” tips for visiting Pinehurst if you are planning a trip.
Pinehurst is a lovely resort and easy to get around because they have a free shuttle service that will take you to all the courses, hotels, and dinning options around the resort and in the village of Pinehurst. It’s fun to just hang out at “The Deuce” at the main club house and watch golfers play the 18th green, Pinehurst #2. We also loved playing the 18 hole “Thistle Dhu” putting course. “Thistle Dhu” is Scottish and translates to “this will do.” We had two matches (I won one match and my friend won the other – on the line was a transfusion drink). We did not play the “Cradle” (the short course). Past experience shaped our decision to not play. We had played the short course (The Hay) at Pebble Beach – hitting off mats for the lovely price of $65 – which was nothing special and felt like playing our local short courses. The Cradle is $50 (and yes, you hit off a mat). It was very busy so I’m sure folks enjoyed it but it was not something we felt we needed to experience.
We played Pinehurst #4 on day one, Tobacco Road on day two, non-golf day on day three, played Pinehurst #8 on day four and ended the trip playing Pinehurst #2 on day five. It was a great mix of golf and relaxing (walking around Pinehurst Village and near by Southern Pines) but this is a golf trip so let’s talk golf.
Overall Impressions of Courses
By the Numbers – All the courses were beautiful, in excellent condition, and challenging to play. To get a sense of the challenge of the courses I looked up the ratings for each on the USGA National Course Rating Database (see the chart below). For my non-golf friends, the first number is an indication of the course difficulty for a scratch golfer (e.g., if par is 72 they play to that number) and the second number is “slope” and indication of the relative difficulty of a golf course for players who are not scratch players compared to players who are scratch players. And the USGA also provides a potential score for bogey golfers. The USGA course rating system lists a male bogey golfer as a 20 handicap and a female bogey golfer as a 24 handicap. For my golfing friends that are wondering about the handicaps — the USGA course rating uses driving distance in determining bogey handicaps (and states the average drive for females is 150 yards). So if you are a female with a 24 handicap index you can set an expectation of a score of 103 (or about three strokes over your “target score” calculated as the course par plus your course handicap: 72+28=100). I personally like to use the GHIN app and look up my course handicap (which is the strokes you get for that course and is not the same as your handicap index) to calculate my target score.
The Chart below shows that Pinehurst #2 is the hardest course. As a non-scratch golfer, I care about the slope of 133 (which is fairly significant against an average course rating slope of 113). Also, the bogey rating is 103.3 for Pinehurst #2. It is interesting that the front 9 slope is easier than the back 9 slope because the caddie said the first six holes of Pinehurst #2 are the hardest.
My opinion on each course…
In many reviews and articles I read before my trip the overall opinion was that Pinehurst #4 was becoming the new favorite (even more so than #2). I disagree (and so did my golf buddy, Donna). We thought both were pretty and challenging but we preferred #2 over #4. In short, the two main differences between #2 and #4 is that #4 had more elevation change than #2 and the sand and grass in the waste areas was different – the waste area for #2 was easier for us to advance the ball farther down the fairways.
Anyway, the easiest way to distinguish the courses are a paragraph on each…
Pinehurst #2 – Everyone said “get ready to get beat up by Pinehurst #2” but that was not my experience. Yes, it was the most difficult course and for women I believe it’s not just the fast greens but also the length. The tee to green yardage for many holes meant I often could not get to the green in regulation or I was hitting a wood into the green which made “holding the fast greens difficult.” For example, Par 3, 17th hole played 167 yards (all carry per Chris our caddie) taking into consideration the elevated green protected on the right by a large bunker. That is basically a driver for most women. On most of the Par 4 holes, it was driver and three wood into the greens and, as I mentioned earlier, that makes holding a green very difficult. With respect to the waste areas, the sand was hard packed so once you realize you could hit a wood or hybrid in the area, it really wasn’t too penalizing unless your ball landed in a “love bush.” Even with the challenges Pinehurst #2 was enjoyable to play. One of the things that surprised me was how peaceful and relax I felt walking Pinehurst #2.
Pinehurst #4 – I expected to really like this course given the reviews but it was my least favorite of the four I played. It was very pretty, hillier than Pinehurst #2 (but nothing like the elevation changes at my local course in the foothills of South Carolina). We did not walk the course because it was noon and a bit warmer; but in the crisp fall mornings, I think it would be an easy walk.
The defense of the course in my opinion was the length (especially on the Par 4 holes) and the sand and grass in the waste areas. After playing #2 and #4, we decided it was much harder to advance your ball out of the waste areas on Pinehurst #4 because the sand was sort of soft and fluffy and the grass was more spread out. Comparatively, the sand in the waste areas at Pinehurst #2 was hard packed. But it really was the distance on some very long par 4 holes on #4 that seemed almost unfair; even my caddie would say to me you can’t get on this par 4 in two (and I was hitting my drives great that day for me at 170-180 yards and my 3 wood 130-140 yards but not reaching a par 4 at 340 or 356 yards). On the bright side, the Par 3s distances were reasonable ranging 90 to 135; but again for any short hitter they would be looking at a hybrid or wood to get on in regulation on the longer par 3s.
Pinehurst #8 – This is a great course for women (and men). It is rated the same as Pinehurst #4 with a slope of 124 but the individual holes have yardages tee to green that are much more manageable because there is a chance you can reach many holes in regulation. It feels a bit more like a course many golfers are use to playing with traditional fairway and green-side bunkers. Yes, there are waste areas but not on every hole or as exceedingly large as the waste areas on #4 and #2. The real challenges at #8 are the really fast greens. The greens were significantly faster than #2 or #4. The reason is that the greens are “new” – all the turf was replaced 18 months ago. I mentioned the fast greens at Pinehurst #8 to our caddie at Pinehurst #2 and he agreed with my assessment. The caddie even told me Pinehurst caddies have a hard time reading the “immature greens at #8.” So my guess is when the greens are “mature,” Pinehurst #8 will be a really fun scoring course.
Tobacco Road Golf Course – This course is in Sanford, NC and is about a half hour drive from the Pinehurst Resort. This course should be on your golf itinerary when you go to the sand hills of North Carolina. It is the most visually stunning of all the courses we played with pristine fairways and huge mounts shaping the terrain; as well as exceedingly large waste areas and every hole was protected by bunkers (some very deep). There were many blind shots and you had to ring a bell on five of the holes so the players behind you knew when it was clear to hit. Our playing partners (men hitting from “Disc” tees at 6,317 yards) described it as “playing on the moon” given they were often hitting over the vast waste areas or playing from them. Often times you would ride your golf cart into the waste area/bunker areas to walk up to the greens.
If your game is not in good shape (e.g., you cannot control your direction or you are not a good sand player) you will probably have a hard time at Tobacco Road. Some call the course quirky, I just call it “a blast” to play.
My Game Overall – So you may be wondering how I did based on the opinions above. I will share with you that I really prepared (practicing every part of my game, taking lessons, etc.) the weeks before this trip. My lowest score was at Tobacco Road with a 86 (with eight pars, six one-putts) which was one stroke better than my target score; but I played well all week and basically played within four strokes of my target scores for each Pinehurst course which means (according to USGA guidelines of four strokes within your target score) I played to my ability – see the chart below – courses are in order of play.
If I look at my pars, bogies, etc. by course (which is a stat in GHIN if you post hole-by-hole with stats), I’m really happy with the results for the four rounds (72 holes) resulting in 65% Bogies or Better (Pars 22% and Bogies 43%).
So, I was really hitting it well and I’m very happy with my scores. Perhaps my biggest take away about my play was that I could say I gave too much respect to the greens because I left so many putts on the edge of the cup. As an optimist I would say that it was great lag putting! LOL
At Pinehurst #4, the first day I had four par putts and one birdie putt that rolled to the edge of the hole. At Tobacco Road I did a much better job with speed with six one-putts but still left some putts on the edge of the cup. This continued with every round. At #8, I had a chance at birdie putts on every Par 3 and the first ones were short and the final one I got to the hole and lipped out. Even on Pinehurst #2 I had a chance to par Hole 1 and I left the putt short. I just think all the folks telling me that the greens were fast and get ready to three and four putt (or get “Donald Rossed” which means you are on the green putting and your putt roles off the green) got in my head and I just never putted with freedom. I did have some three putts but not as many as I anticipated; so perhaps leaving putts short at Pinehurst was not such a bad “miss.”
Thanks for reading my blog and if you want to see more pictures (photo gallery at the end of each post) and more details on playing each course click on the links for each course: Pinehurst #2, Pinehurst #4, Pinehurst #8 and Tobacco Road. If you do go to the detail course blogs please know that I wrote them to document my play (for myself) — so you have been warned that it might bore you to death reading those posts but at least you can quickly scroll and enjoy the photos.
If you are looking for tips on planning a trip to Pinehurst Resort, see my blog post titled “Pinehurst Non-golf Tips.”
A few photos of some Pinehurst SWAG
The image of “bucket list sign” and yardage books earlier in this blog post were purchased and I also bought a zip sweater, ball markers, a cap. The ball marker from Tobacco Road is cool. Believe it or not, I actually controlled my spending (purchased much less than I did at Pebble Beach – ha,ha).
Also, each course at Pinehurst had tees (# on top of tee, different stripes on sides) and plastic ball markers for golfers to take at the 1st hole. Unfortunately at #2 there were no plastic ball markers.